File Name: on suffering and structural violence a view from below .zip
Those systems include income inequality, racism, homophobia, anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, sexism, ableism, and other means of social exclusion leading to vulnerabilities, such as poverty, stress, trauma, crime, incarceration, lack of access to care, healthy food, and physical activity. Structural violence are social forces that harm certain groups of people, producing and perpetuating inequality in health and well-being.
Pathologies of Power uses harrowing stories of life—and death—in extreme situations to interrogate our understanding of human rights. With passionate eyewitness accounts from the prisons of Russia and the beleaguered villages of Haiti and Chiapas, this book links the lived experiences of individual victims to a broader analysis of structural violence. Farmer challenges conventional thinking within human rights circles and exposes the relationships between political and economic injustice, on one hand, and the suffering and illness of the powerless, on the other.
Haiti is impacted by structural violence , a form of dysfunction where social structures prevent certain groups of people from having access to basic human rights , like education and healthcare. Additionally, Haitians are financially impoverished and within Haiti, there exist social inequalities. In , While there has been some international assistance, there are insufficient supportive infrastructures in place within the country to provide resources and opportunities for Haitians who are trying to attain a higher quality of life.
Causes that have resulted in higher levels of structural violence within Haiti include political instability and corruption , as well as the impact of post-colonialism , which has established a caste -based class system within Haiti.
As defined by Medical Anthropologist Dr. Paul Farmer , structural violence is the way by which social arrangements are constructed to put specific members of a population in harm's way. Farmer , social inequalities are at the heart of structural violence, where the prevailing societal framework imposes invisible barriers that perpetuate the suffering of certain groups of people.
The term further gained exposure when it was used by Latin American liberation theologians. The term violence highlights the fact that these structures cause injury or inequality to certain groups of peoples and constrain individual agency in the society in which they operate. While the negative effects of structural violence affects almost everyone in the nation of Haiti , there are a number of social factors that render certain demographics of the population to experience a more severe form of human suffering.
These include gender , ethnicity and socioeconomic status. While structural violence impacts Haiti as a whole, due to the presence of gender inequality , women within Haiti tend to be more heavily impacted by structural violence than men. Racial or ethnic differentiation has been well acknowledged as a means of depriving certain racial or ethnic groups of basic human rights , or from receiving the same quality of resources as others.
The Human Suffering Index HSI , which examines measures of human welfare ranging from life expectancy to political freedom , listed Haiti to be one of the 27 of countries characterized by "extreme human suffering". The impacts of structural violence are far reaching. They affect individuals, and overall social outcomes. These basic rights include access to healthcare and education. As identified by the World Development Report, health and education are two key human capital endowments that can influence an individual's ability to reach his or her full potential in society.
In , Haiti was the poorest nation in the Western Hemisphere , with approximately Structural violence impacts one's ability to receive education. The quality of education is low due to the lack of organization, expertise, and resources. There is a shortage of school supplies and qualified teachers. This problem is more prevalent in rural areas.
Serviced by a mixture of the public sector , the private sector , the non-profit sector, and religious institutions, the health system in Haiti faces the challenge of establishing efficient health coordination. Additionally, medical services, whether public or private are disproportionately located in the metropolitan Port-au-Prince area.
Hospitals outside the Port-au-Prince area provide limited obstetric services. In rural areas, prenatal care services are often delivered either by outreach teams or by small clinics that do not have formal maternity wards or delivery capabilities.
While most medical infrastructures are concentrated within Port-au-Prince, these hospitals and clinical facilities are often in a dilapidated state as they are compromised by infrastructural deficiencies and electrical blackouts. This lack of medical infrastructure was further exacerbated by the Haiti earthquake. Access to healthcare also includes issues like perceived quality of care. This under-utilization of existing rural services is directly tied to the perceived and actual quality of the facilities.
Structural violence impacts health outcomes at both an individual and communal level. Individually, structural violence creates barriers that prevent one from properly receiving and utilizing health care systems. Some of these barriers include high user fees, which lower health facility utilization levels, as well as social stigma around certain diseases that reduce utilization and thus negatively impact health outcomes for certain individuals.
This public separation thus makes visible the social stigma of sexually transmitted diseases , which can deter women from utilizing certain sex-related health services. This uneven distribution of resources across Haiti's society has created numerous social and economic disparities, all of which have led the country to perform below other countries in a series of health outcomes. According to the World Health Organization data on health indicators, the average life expectancy in Haiti at birth is 61 years for males and 64 years for females, lower than the global average of 70 years.
Mortality rates in Haiti are higher than world averages across all demographics. Today, Haiti has the highest rates of infant , under-five, and maternal mortality in the Western hemisphere. The probability of infants dying under the age of five is 76 per 1, live births. The lack of development and spending on healthcare resources and services makes Haitians , particularly those living in rural areas , susceptible to diseases that are otherwise manageable.
In the World Malaria Report, confirmed cases of malaria in Haiti tripled from 16, to 49, between and By the end of , a total of , cases, including 3, deaths were reported in Haiti.
One cause that has resulted in significant levels of structural violence within Haiti is political instability and corruption. There has been a long [ clarification needed ] history of oppression by dictators. Another cause of structural violence is the impact of post-colonialism. During the 19th century, European expansion into the New World created social arrangements such as slavery and institutionalized racism.
The remnants of these social structures exist today in the form of caste -based racial discrimination , which contributes to the social inequality and economic disparities present within Haiti.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Overview about structural violence in Haiti. Berkeley: University of California Press. The World Bank. Retrieved 16 March Library of Congress. Retrieved 19 June Retrieved 31 March The Lancet. Social Forces. Comparative American Studies. PLOS Medicine.
Current Anthropology. Retrieved 15 March Addendum: Report on the mission to Haiti Report. UN Commission on Human Rights. Department of State. Berkeley [u. Journal of Human Development. Poverty and inequality Orig. Stanford, Calif. Feminist Economics. Webster University. Dordrecht: Springer. Gender equality and development: world development report Retrieved 24 April June International Monetary Fund, Washington, D. Archived from the original PDF on 14 September Archived from the original PDF on 22 September Public health risk assessment and interventions.
World Health Organization. World Development Report International Bank for Reconstruction and Development Report. Sanctions in Haiti: Crisis in Humanitarian Action. Harvard Center for Population and Development Studies. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry. Disability and Rehabilitation. Preventing maternal deaths PDF Report. Port-au-Prince, Haiti. Childbearing, Sickness and Healing in a Haitian Village. Boulder, San Francisco: Westview Press. International Journal of Health Services. International Health.
Journal of Women's Health. Journal of Peace Research. Retrieved 17 March Central Intelligence Agency. New England Journal of Medicine. World malaria report PDF.
This article examines the interrelationships among structural violence, poverty and social suffering. It begins with a vignette from Haiti, the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, that puts a face on structural violence. It then traces the historical roots and characteristic features of the concept of structural violence and goes on to discuss its relationship to other types of violence. It also considers how the notion of structural violence has been applied across various disciplines to enhance our understanding of social problems linked to profound poverty and social suffering. Furthermore, it describes the utility and relevance of structural violence to social analysis before concluding with an overview of how anthropology can be used in refining the concept of structural violence. Keywords: structural violence , poverty , social suffering , Haiti , social problems , social analysis , anthropology. Access to the complete content on Oxford Handbooks Online requires a subscription or purchase.
Where do we see instances of structural violence take shape in the past, as well as in the present day? Fans of the popular post-apocalyptic zombie thriller The Walking Dead will recall the scene where Morgan, a significant character in the series, is trapped inside a prison cell in the cabin of a man he has just met. Days pass yet continues to Morgan remain in the cell. Why then did Morgan stay? This scene in popular media illustrates the phenomenon of structural or institutionalized violence. In this specific situation, Morgan suffers from the environment around him: a world littered with disorder, hostility, and inhumanity. Even though the cell door is just metal shaped to the will of humans, it bears a much more significant effect on its inhabitant.
PLoS Med 3 10 : e This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. Because of contact with patients, physicians readily appreciate that large-scale social forces—racism, gender inequality, poverty, political violence and war, and sometimes the very policies that address them—often determine who falls ill and who has access to care. For practitioners of public health, the social determinants of disease are even harder to disregard. Unfortunately, this awareness is seldom translated into formal frameworks that link social analysis to everyday clinical practice.
This article examines the interrelationships among structural violence, poverty and social suffering. It begins with a vignette from Haiti, the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, that puts a face on structural violence. It then traces the historical roots and characteristic features of the concept of structural violence and goes on to discuss its relationship to other types of violence. It also considers how the notion of structural violence has been applied across various disciplines to enhance our understanding of social problems linked to profound poverty and social suffering. Furthermore, it describes the utility and relevance of structural violence to social analysis before concluding with an overview of how anthropology can be used in refining the concept of structural violence.
Don't have an account? The act of simply noting the presence or absence of skeletal trauma is not enough; bioarchaeologists need to expand and take more into consideration as violence involves much more than trauma.
Some , unskilled and prevalently male Nepali labourers work in Qatar as per an agreement between the governments of the two countries. They are the lowest level of the genetically engineered pyramid of some two million migrant workers that represent some 90 per cent of the resident population in Qatar. Based on ethnographic fieldwork in Nepal and Qatar, this chapter analyses social transformations in rural Nepal, the exploitative regulation of migration and the human condition of Nepali migrants in Qatar as well as the meanings ascribed to it.
This article examines the interrelationships among structural violence, poverty and social suffering. It begins with a vignette from Haiti, the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, that puts a face on structural violence. It then traces the historical roots and characteristic features of the concept of structural violence and goes on to discuss its relationship to other types of violence.